design process etiketine sahip kayıtlar gösteriliyor. Tüm kayıtları göster
design process etiketine sahip kayıtlar gösteriliyor. Tüm kayıtları göster

A classification of argument types for product aesthetics

This paper focuses on the creative process of designing products with aesthetic qualities. Within this creative process, the paper focuses on the kinds of argumentation that designers use to justify aesthetic qualities of design objects. A distinctive feature of such arguments is the highly subjective nature of aesthetic preferences. Therefore, instead of actual observable phenomena, the focus is always on someone's subjective opinion. To address this issue, a basis is taken in established argumentation models, which are transformed into the described context. The proposed classification's fit with the reality of industrial designers was investigated through a series of interviews with industrial designers. The studies illustrated that all the eight developed argument types are, in fact, applied in practice.
 
C&C '13 Proceedings of the 9th ACM Conference on Creativity & Cognition 

Minimizing change aversion for the google drive launch

Change aversion is a natural response, which technology often exacerbates. Evolutionary changes can be subtle and occur over many generations. But Internet users must sometimes deal with sudden, significant product changes to applications they rely on and identify with. Despite the best intentions of designers and product managers, users often experience anxiety and confusion when faced with a new interface or changed functionality. While some change aversion is often inevitable, it can also be managed and minimized with the right steps. This case study describes how our understanding of change aversion helped minimize negative effects for the transition of the Google Docs List to Google Drive, a product for file storage in the cloud. We describe actions that allowed for a launch with no aversion.

CHI EA '13 CHI '13 Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems 

Validating constraint driven design techniques in spatial augmented reality

We describe new techniques to allow constraint driven design using spatial augmented reality (SAR), using projectors to animate a physical prop. The goal is to bring the designer into the visual working space, interacting directly with a dynamic design, allowing for intuitive interactions, while gaining access to affordance through the use of physical objects. We address the current industrial design process, expressing our intended area of improvement with the use of SAR. To corroborate our hypothesis, we have created a prototype system, which we have called SARventor. Within this paper, we describe the constraint theory we have applied, the interaction techniques devised to help illustrate our ideas and goals, and finally the combination of all input and output tasks provided by SARventor.
To validate the new techniques, an evaluation of the prototype system was conducted. The results of this evaluation indicated promises for a system allowing a dynamic design solution within SAR. Design experts see potential in leveraging SAR to assist in the collaborative process during industrial design sessions, offering a high fidelity, transparent application, presenting an enhanced insight into critical design decisions to the projects stakeholders. Through the rich availability of affordance in SAR, designers and stakeholders have the opportunity to see first-hand the effects of the proposed design while considering both the ergonomic and safety requirements.

Thinking product meeting contexts into the design process

Cambridge Academic Design Management conference 2013

Understanding Innovation: Playing in the Sandbox with Friends

Can anyone learn to be more innovative? Innovation may not be a matter of learning but of unlearning. We have in us an instinctive drive designed to push us to learn and experience important principles of innovation, things like; curiosity, discovery, exploration, experimentation, communicating, and socializing (Elkind 2008). This instinctive drive is called play. Play has been shown to be crucial to the development of these skills by decades of research. This is especially true of the purest form of play: the unstructured, self-motivated, imaginative, independent kind, where people initiate their own games and even invent their own rules (Elkind 2008). Children are intrinsically motivated to play and they learn at tremendous rates in their formative years. (Bowler 1997) but then at an early age efforts are made to try and control their natural tendencies and inclinations for learning and communicate to them that it is time to stop playing and start working, it is time for school. It is time to control those physical urges and sit still, it is time for learning a set of rules, and it is time to stop talking to your neighbor. Not to say that the principles of work are not important but they can work hand-in-hand with play to create a fairly accurate model for innovation. It is time to push back and provide opportunities for unlearning those things that limit our creativity and relearn those important attributes gained through principles of play.

8th International Conference on Design Principles and Practices

A Dual Verification Model for Designing Home Use Medical Devices

Increasingly, medical devices are being used by lay people outside the clinical
environment (FDA, 2010; Gardner-Bonneau, 2011). These are frequently called
home use medical devices (HUMD). A HUMD is defined as “a medical device
intended for users in a non-clinical or transitory environment, is managed
partly or wholly by the user, requires adequate labelling for the user, and may
require training for the user by a licensed health care provider in order to be
used safely and effectively” (FDA, 2010).
The process of designing a HUMD differs from consumer products, because
although these devices are used by lay people, they are medical devices which
are safety critical and subject to regulatory requirements (Gupta, 2007; FDA,
2012). On the other hand, as lay users differ significantly from professionals
in terms of their needs and capabilities, the design process of HUMD requires
a different approach than medical devices designed for professional use
(Wiklund & Wilcox, 2005). Despite many generic design process models (e.g.
Pugh, 1991; French, 1999; Stanton, 2004; Clarkson et al, 2007; Pahl et al, 2007)
and guidance and models for medical device (e.g. FDA, 1997; Alexander, et al.,
2001; Alexander & Clarkson, 2002), little information was identified regarding
the design process for HUMD.
In order to support designers, a new model was developed which involves five
stages, i.e. discovering the needs, task clarification, design, testing and final
validation. The model highlights the importance of understanding regulatory
requirements and lay user requirements, and also emphasises the validation
and verification activities. It is called the “Dual Verification Model for Designing
Home Use Medical Devices” (Figure 1).

This paper will discuss how the regulatory requirements and lay user requirments were captured, how the model was developed, and what potential
value it might have to designers.

D4H2013

INNOVATION WITHOUT DESIGN: THE DYNAMICS OF ROLE MAKING AND THE GRADUAL EMERGENCE OF THE COLLECTIVE DESIGNER

This paper explores innovation and social behaviourist theory in relation to sustainable urban projects in the highly institutionalized public sector (towns). Using empirical data from France, we examine the dynamics of a design process in which unexpected practices generated innovative urban design. We show how the fact that the design process did not follow the standard phases of planning meant that the actors redefined themselves in relation to one another. We point out how the absence of urban design plans during a precise phase of an innovative design process drew the actors into a movement of collective action, which presupposed the acquisition of a new identity. Ultimately, our objective is to combine social behaviourist theory and innovation theory and to facilitate innovative design in urban projects.

ICDC2012 Glasgow

INVESTIGATING THE DEVELOPMENT OF IMAGINATIVE AND CREATIVE CAPACITY IN PRODUCT DESIGN

This research was conducted through a literature review, case studies, and interviews with experts on award-winning works in international design competitions. Through qualitative analysis of these design projects, we identified several paths leading from imaginative constructs to conceptual development in the design process: thematic relationships, intersecting attributes, the transfer of attributes, inherited attributes, causal relationships, analogical relationships, multi-level inclusive relationships, and the interpretation of contrasting meaning. Lastly, statistical analysis was used to determine the weight of each conceptual development mode in the design process. Results show that the most significant mode of conceptual development in the overall design process is causal relationships, followed in decreasing order by multi-level inclusive relationships, thematic relationships, the transfer of attributes, analogical relationships, inherited attributes, intersecting attributes, and lastly, the transfer of attributes. It is hoped that the results of this study will serve as a useful reference in design education, particularly with regard to the development of imaginative and creative capacity.

ICDC2012 Glasgow

The Influence of Design Methods on the Design Process: Effect of use of scenario, brainstorming, and synectics on designing

This paper presents the results of protocol analyses of collaborative design
sessions to examine whether the use of different design methods influences
the design process. Nine collaborative design sessions using brainstorming,
scenario, synectics were analyzed using the function-behavior-structure
ontology. The frequencies and distributions of percentages of design issues
and design processes were statistically analyzed to determine differences in
the design processes caused by the use of different design methods. The
results indicate that the use of different design methods influences the
design process and the differences appear early on in the design sessions.
Brainstorming was more oriented toward functional thinking. Scenario was
more oriented towards the design of customer-oriented products by
simulating various expected behaviors in context. Synectics was more
oriented towards the thinking of product structures and their combination.
When dividing the design sessions into three sections, it was found that the
influences of the design methods were most pronounced in the early design
stage of the conceptual design process. This research contributes to a better
understanding of the use of design methods from a design cognition point of
view.

DRS 2012 Bangkok

Observational Research and Verbal Protocol Methods

This paper describes observational research and verbal protocols methods,
how these methods are applied and integrated within different contexts, and
how they complement each other.
The first case study focuses on nurses’ interaction during bandaging of
patients’ lower legs. To maintain research rigor a triangulation approach
was applied that links observations of current procedures, ‘talk-aloud’
protocol during interaction and retrospective protocol. Maps of interactions
demonstrated that some nurses bandage more intuitively than others.
Nurses who bandage intuitively assemble long sequences of bandaging
actions while nurses who bandage less intuitively ‘focus-shift’ in between
bandaging actions. Thus different levels of expertise have been identified.
The second case study consists of two laboratory experiments. It focuses on
analysing and comparing software and product design teams and how they
approached a design problem. It is based on the observational and verbal
data analysis. The coding scheme applied evolved during the analysis of the
activity of each team and is identical for all teams. The structure of
knowledge captured from the analysis of the design team maps of
interaction is identified.
The significance of this work is within its methodological approach. The
maps of interaction are instrumental for understanding the activities and
interactions of the people observed. By examining the maps of interaction, it
is possible to draw conclusions about interactions, structure of knowledge
captured and level of expertise. This research approach is transferable to
other design domains. Designers will be able to transfer the interaction
maps outcomes to systems and services they design.

DRS 2012 Bangkok

Emotion: New DNA in design process

This paper presents a design methodology to captivate emotions in the design process. The
paper shares examples from the student projects for designing houseware products. The
goal was to design consumers’ products that would have substantial and stable emotional
connection. It aims to design a product lasting longer. The emphasis was on the emotional
bond between the consumer and product. The element, ‘emotion’ has been started getting
attention in the design research process in order to compensate the conventional design
process activities. This paper provides the three components for deeper understanding of
consumers' needs in order to implement emotion in the design process.
1.'Security Blanket Theory(S.B.T)': Providing psychological comfort to the users and the
product lasts longer by adding feeling or emotions as design elements obtained from the
users.
2. ‘Metaphor Investigation and Interpretation (Mi2)’: Metaphors reveal the vital cues for
what the customers genuinely want and mean.
3.'Emotion Equalization (E2)' is required in the design process in order to make the product
last long.
By integrating the new components in the design process, the students had an opportunity
to think about the design process as whole experience, a moment the consumers purchase
products, and even after using the products. As a result, the students tried to establish
emotional bonding between the users and products rather than designing outside of
appearance.

DRS 2012 Bangkok

Does SKETCHING Stand Alone as a Communication Tool during CONCEPT GENERATION in DESIGN Teams?

The present study investigates the relation between sketching and communication in teams
a
during the idea generation process in early concept generation. A quasi-experiment study
has been conducted with Masters students of Industrial Design Engineering at Delft
University of Technology, Netherlands. Six groups consisting of three students had to solve
a design problem in a given time. Whereas the experimental groups (n=3) were not allowed
to talk during the design process, the control groups (n=3) did not face any restrictions.
The experiments were recorded, observed and analyzed.
As expected, both groups used
communication to transfer and support their individual ideas. For the experimental groups,
the written language became the medium of communication in detailing the information of
sketches. These findings show that sketching cannot stand alone; design teams need to use
sketching and verbal communication in conjunction not only to produce well-developed
ideas, but also to transfer them.

DRS 2012 Bangkok

Towards a Formal Evaluation of Creativity in Parametric Design Process: A pilot study

Parametric design has become an emerging research issue in the design domain. However,
our current understanding of creativity in the parametric design process is very limited.
This study presents a formal approach for describing and identifying cognitive thinking and
activities for evaluating creativity in parametric design process using protocol analysis.
This coding scheme is based on the creative acts: Representation, Perception, and
Searching for a solution. Also, it provides Geometry and Algorithm categories to capture
the cognitive activity in the parametric design process. The effectiveness of this formal
approach was examined in a pilot study. The percentage of coverage of geometric and
algorithmic cognitions results in a better understanding of the parametric design process
over a time period. The normalised value of the coverage percentage allows us to explore
three levels of design cognition in terms of creativity. This research contributes to the
development and verification of a formal approach for evaluating creativity in parametric
designing. With this formal approach, this research provides a promising procedure, not
yet available, of capturing cognitive activity and identifying creative patterns in the
parametric design process.

DRS 2012 Bangkok

Co-creating with Companies: A design led process of learning

Design emerged and spread at the beginning of the industrial era in a
strongly industrial and product-oriented environment. Therefore it
developed and consolidated around the notion of industrial product. Today,
different voices are calling for a new role for design as a driver of
innovation. Especially the notion of co-design, intended as the process of
involving customers and end users in developing new products and services
has been largely discussed as a source of competitive advantage and as a
key element of innovation for companies. Co-design can help companies in
generating new and alternative solutions that can satisfy the market needs
mainly exploiting approaches and tools that allow customers to express
their creativity. On the contrary scarce attention has been spent on the
phenomenon of “co-designing with companies”, as a participated design
process that takes place between professional designers and people working
in companies. This form of co-design shows different characteristics with
respect to co-designing with end users. It emerges as a complex process
that: (i) aims to apply design methods and competences to investigate the
current problems that impair a company to innovate; (ii) considers codesigners
as
experts,
who
bring
into
the
innovation
process
their
expertise,

along
with
the
company’s
culture,
values,
rules,
processes,
technologies

(which
may
at
the
same
time
impair
or
enable
innovation);
(iii)
is
a learning

process,
during
which
co-designers
can
observe
and
make
practice
with
the

way
in
which
designers
investigate
the
space
of
a problem
and develop

visions
of
the
future
that
can
support
innovation;
(iii)
normally
ends
with

ideas
for
artifacts
and services,
but
also
with
intangibles
results,
such
as

new
business
models,
new
processes
and rules,
new
competences,
new

organizational
structures,
which
may
affect
the
company’s
vision,
strategy,

culture,
leadership
and processes
of
development,
pushing
the
company

towards
transformational
changes.

DRS 2012 Bangkok

Workshop Process for Design Education by Using AEIOU Approach to Wayfinding Application

The wayfinding application of AEIOU approach design workshop is an operationalism
oriented design methodology in which design college students worked together to find the
real world wayfinding problems and then analyze, represent, test, and finally design a
problem solving product or service. The AEIOU approach is articulated to A (activity), E
(environment), I (individual), O (objects), and U (understanding). It was designed based on
the Situation-Framework-Solution Mode that consisted with Situation-problem (analysis),
Framework-lenses (evaluation), and Solution-prototype (synthesis), the evidence-based
design process. The most important concept to be learned is the attitude of “empathy” and
“reflection-in-action”.
The workshop process was operated based on the following steps: (1) Define situationproblem;
(2)
Select
framework
to
analyze;
(3)
Represent
Lynch’s
framework;
(4)
Use

Lynch’s
analysis
method;
(5)
Analyze
representation; (6) Evaluate the collected and
represented data; (7) Develop representations of the evaluation (seeing & imaging
drawings ); (8) Synthesize the requirements or opportunities into beta solution method; (9)
Prototype imagining drawings; (10) Evaluate the solutions-synthesis against the problem
situation and test; (11) Repeat (iterate) steps 1-10 until the cost-benefit is negative.
The conclusions and feedbacks generated from the workshop were three pedagogical
evaluation contents: (1) The website sharing and information presentation are helpful to
the workshop pedagogical method. (2) Most of the students felt “freedom but serious” in
the overall process control. With the satisfaction feedback, the students revealed high
positive attitude about their final design works and their work performance. (3) The most
impressive part of the workshop process was “prototype testing”. According to the
opinions of students, most of them were first time to make prototype testing with the real
users.

DRS 2012 Bangkok

ilo Cards: A tool to support the design of interactive artifacts

In this paper we describe the "i|o cards", a tool comprising 31 paper cards
that enables participants from different backgrounds to engage in creative
collaborative activities in the design of interactive artifacts. These artifacts
comprehend a wide range of design products in which physical instance and
electronic behavior are integrated. Three workshops are described to
illustrate different contexts and methods where the tool was already applied.
The data gathered in the activities was used to improve the cards and to
attest its role in improving certain aspects of the design process. At the end,
four ways in which the i|o cards can be used to support creative activities
are discussed.

DRS 2012 Bangkok

A comparison of Diary Method Variations for Enlightening Form Generation in the Design Process

This paper presents two studies in which an empirical approach was taken to understand
and explain form generation and decisions taken in the design process. In particular, the
activities addressing aesthetic aspects when exteriorizing form ideas in the design process
have been the focus of the present study. Diary methods were the starting point of this
research for investigating the form generation process through collecting self-reflective
comments from the participants. The main focus of this paper is to address potentials and
limitations of the three variants of diary method used for data collection, namely,
unstructured diaries, structured diaries and visual diaries. A set of method evaluation
criteria was developed to compare the structure of the diary variants. By qualitative
analysis of the results and comparison of the diary variants, strengths and weaknesses of
each variant were identified. One of the prominent factors in the diary variants was pegged
to be due to the logging delay after the occurrence of the activities.

DRS 2012 Bangkok

Yours or Mine? Role sharing between industrial design and interaction design

As a profession, industrial design has been affected by different dynamics throughout its
history. One of the dynamics which affected industrial design strongly is the arrival of new
technology. One of the fields in which information technology revolution happened is the
arrival of micro-electronics, particularly in the area of telecommunication. This created an
entirely new area of professional practice which was first named user interface design, but
then developed to become a new professional practice, interaction design.
Although interaction design is a growing profession today, interaction designers often have
to explain what an interaction designer actually does and argue that their specialty is not
something that anyone could do without a formal education both to stakeholders and
clients who buy their designs. Furthermore there still seems to be confusion when the job of
industrial designers and interaction designers are overviewed together.
The aim of this paper is to build a background for role sharing in design processes with a
specific focus on industrial design and interaction design.
Role sharing in design processes is highly related with design practice. Thus the empirical
data for this research has been gathered through two sets of interviews and also a
validating case study based on a product’s design process.
There are significant parts of the design process in which interaction design and industrial
design collaborate. The closest and the most intense collaboration take place in early
phases of design process such as concept generation and creation of design alternatives
which are explored in-depth in the paper.

DRS 2012 Bangkok